Google vs. Instagram: Where Should Restaurants Focus Their Online Energy?

If you’re a restaurant owner trying to build an online presence, you’ve probably asked yourself this question:

Should I focus more on Google or Instagram?

And the honest answer? Both—just not in the same way.

Google helps people find you.
 Instagram helps people connect with you.

They serve different purposes—but when used together strategically, they drive real traffic to your door (and your table).

Google: Be Found First

Think of Google as your digital front door. When someone searches “best tacos near me” or “cocktail bar in Scottsdale,” Google decides if you show up. That’s where your Google Business Profile comes in.

Here’s what to prioritize:

  • Accurate info (hours, address, website, etc.)

  • High-quality photos (food, interior, people)

  • Up-to-date menu

  • Recent reviews (and your replies!)

Even if you’re crushing it on social, a neglected Google listing can cost you valuable visibility—especially with locals and tourists using Maps or voice search.

Instagram: Build the Vibe

Instagram isn’t where most people start their search—but it’s often where they fall in love with your brand.

Your feed gives people a taste of your experience:

  • What the food looks like

  • What the space feels like

  • Who’s dining there

  • What kind of night they’re about to have

And reels? They’re not just pretty—they’re powerful. A great reel can introduce your spot to thousands of new people and get shared like crazy. Plus, Instagram lets you build community, show personality, and create repeat guests through consistent content.

So Where Should You Focus?

If you’re just starting out:

  1. Get your Google Business Profile polished first. It’s low effort, high reward.

  2. Then put energy into Instagram, where you can tell your story, show your space, and build loyal fans.

If you’re already up and running:

  • Use Google to make sure new customers can find you.

  • Use Instagram to give them a reason to choose you—and keep coming back.

Need help showing up strong in both places? At EatDrink Creative Agency, we specialize in scroll-stopping content and smart digital strategies that get guests in the door.  Contact us today and let’s put your online presence to work.

————

Want more insider tips on content creation, social media strategy and the latest industry trends? Sign up HERE for our EatDrink Creative Agency newsletter and get expert insights delivered straight to your inbox!